Society & Culture / Culture & Ideas / Religion & Faith

Why Morality Failed in the West: Isma'il Al Faruqi Explains

Isma'il Raji al-Faruqi

Is morality a real physical law like gravity, or just a fleeting chemical reaction in your brain? Modern science and Western philosophy hit a dead end trying to prove objective good and evil. This breakdown dismantles that crisis through the explosive thought of Isma'il Raji al-Faruqi (1921–1986), the influential Palestinian-American philosopher and scholar of comparative religion, examining his landmark work on value theory, theological ethics, and comparative religion. Slide 1: Morality feels as real as gravity. But science cannot weigh justice in a test tube. Western empiricism reduced all goodness to mere brain chemicals, turning charity and crime into matters of personal taste. Absolute moral chaos. Slide 2: Idealists panicked and claimed values are invisible ghosts floating in space. But without an organizing force, justice and mercy end up in an eternal fistfight. Western philosophy left us trapped between meaningless biology and cosmic anarchy. Slide 3: Al-Faruqi unlocks the forgotten genius of Islamic thought. Drawing on medieval thinker Ibn Taymiyyah, he shows that goodness is not an essence to dissect under a microscope. Goodness is divine will translated into rational ideas. Slide 4: The Adam and Eve story holds the biggest plot twist. It was never a catastrophic fall that permanently broke humanity. It was an educational mistake, instantly forgiven. Humans are not born cursed; they are born responsible. Slide 5: Why did God make an imperfect world full of suffering? A flawless world is static and boring. Imperfection is the deliberate canvas required for free will. You cannot display courage without danger or practice charity without poverty. Slide 6: Modern academia treats living faiths like dead museum specimens, preaching that all paths are identical. Al-Faruqi destroys this lazy relativism. Contradictory claims cannot all be true. Real respect means engaging the ultimate truth with ruthless intellectual courage. You are not a cosmic janitor cleaning up a random mistake. You are an architect tasked with pulling transcendent values into reality through your daily choices.